Wagtail, Virginia, usually offers a peaceful escape, but in this book review of Krista Davis’s The Wagtail Murder Club, #10 in the (Paws & Claws) series, tranquility takes a back seat to a tangled web of secrets and sudden death. The Sugar Maple Inn becomes a hotbed of intrigue when Holly Miller rescues the mysterious Labrador and her ex-boyfriend arrives with a group of suspicious colleagues. Is it just a series of unfortunate accidents, or is a killer lurking in the idyllic town? Get ready to plunge into this delightful cozy mystery that will keep you guessing and smiling, even with its unexpected character arcs.
Disclaimer: Some links found on this page might be affiliate links. If you click an affiliate link and make a purchase, we may earn a commission. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Holly Miller: Amateur Sleuth and the Web of Wagtail Relationships
Holly Miller shines as the determined amateur sleuth, her deep-rooted connection to Wagtail driving her to seek justice and protect her community. The supporting cast, particularly “The Ben,” as Holly’s grandmother pointedly calls him—due to his pushy nature and Holly’s tendency to be a pushover. Yet his legal colleagues, add an extra layer of complexity, embodying the themes of trust and betrayal as their hidden agendas come to light.
The dynamics between these characters create a compelling tension, as Holly must decipher who to trust amidst a web of secrets. And of course, Trixie and Twinkletoes provide both comic relief and invaluable assistance, highlighting the powerful bond between humans and animals that is a recurring theme in the series. However, some of Holly’s personal choices seemed to come out of left field, creating a slight disconnect for me as a reader. This unexpected turn in her personal life, while intended to add depth, felt rushed against the backdrop of the intricate mystery.
Wagtail’s Facade: Unveiling Hidden Truths and Community Bonds
Beyond the compelling character interactions, The Wagtail Murder Club manages to skillfully explore the contrast between appearances and reality. Wagtail, with its picturesque setting and seemingly tranquil atmosphere, initially presents an idyllic facade. However, as the murders unfold, the town’s hidden secrets and darker undercurrents are exposed. This theme of unveiling hidden truths resonates throughout the narrative, mirroring the process of Holly’s investigation.
This particular Sugar Maple Inn mystery further emphasizes the importance of community, showcasing how the townspeople are both drawn together and divided by the unfolding events. Despite the suspicion and distrust that arise, a sense of collective responsibility emerges, highlighting the strength of the bonds that connect Wagtail’s residents. This exploration of community in the face of crisis brings depth to the mystery, elevating it beyond a simple whodunit.
Overall, The Wagtail Murder Club is a solid addition to the (Paws & Claws) Mystery series. The engaging mystery, charming setting, and lovable characters make it a worthwhile read, despite a few personal reservations regarding character development. Cozy mystery fans will enjoy the intrigue and the strong sense of community in Wagtail. You can purchase the book here.
Thanks to Berkley for the #gifted book for this review.
